Scott
Yarmoff
Mrs.
Robbins
Crit
Film Period 3
9/28/14
Citizen
Kane
The
entire plot of the story revolves around the question, “What is the
meaning of 'Rosebud'?” If “Rosebud” is the last thing he says
before he dies, clearly it's been the most important part of his
life. We find out that “Rosebud” is the name of his sled from his
childhood. My question is, how did this come as much of a surprise to
the audience? I understand that people may not have been able to
guess that “Rosebud” was the name of his sled, but we should have
been able to see that it represented something from his childhood.
The
only true time that Kane is portrayed as happy is when he is a kid
playing in the snow outside his home. From the time when Thatcher
takes him away to his death, his only other happy time is when he was
with Susan Alexander the first time they met. In the first scene
where we see Kane die holding a snow globe, we should've been able to
tell that the snow globe represents his childhood, which took place
in the snow just a few scenes later.
From
the time Kane is taken away until his death, the only thing he does
is try to make himself happy. As his 25th birthday
approaches, he is going to be given power to many different companies
but he says he only wants to own one of the small newspaper companies
because he thinks it will be “fun.” He seems very unhappy with
Thatcher and doesn't do what he is supposed to because he wants to be
happy. He gets married to try to be happy. He tries looking for his
mother's remains in a warehouse to “find his youth” and try to be
happy. He instead spends the night with Susan Alexander and is happy.
On
his deathbed, he is trying to take himself back to his only true
happy days: his childhood before he was taken away. That's why he is
holding the snow globe. We, as an audience, should have been able to
tell that the word he said and the object he held were connected, so
we should have been able to see that “Rosebud” was symbolic of
his childhood since he is just trying to “find his youth” and get
back to a happier time throughout the film.
I completely agree. There are several moments of foreshadowing throughout the film. Even some completely overt ones like the shot of Rosebud being buried by the snow. You're right. I never thought of the point about happiness, especially about his thinking it would be fun to run a newspaper. Everything was just casual fun to him, and for the entirety of his early days on the paper, he wears a broad grin 24/7.
ReplyDelete